Return to Region
Post a comment
Exxon and Va Ave Park – Option 1
Associated files:
Comments:
Mark
This would probably be my third choice - generally the land around the old Exxon station - with the obvious exception of the community garden - is currently a bit of a wasteland and any development on that land would be appreciated, particularly if it would allow for the introduction of family housing units. Moreover, the "park" land there is too close to the highway to be used for many activities - such as allowing my kids to play there.
Jenni
There is a vibrant and wonderful community garden located in the Virginia Avenue Park, it needs to remain and perhaps even be expanded to accommodate the huge interest in organic vegetable gardening that exists in our community. There were several meetings in the fall of 2009 to discuss ways to improve and develop the park to make it a better community resource for everyone including dog owners, bicyclists and families. We need to keep the green areas of our community intact and make them better for all to enjoy, not take them away and build large buildings on them.
Jenni
I want to make it clear that it is not a "pro" to relocate the Community Garden. People have spent countless hours and lots of money to make the Garden what it is today. It is not easy to dump some soil in a plot and grow vegetables. It takes years of careful cultivation to create a decent soil environment to grow your food in. The Garden has also received grants to build permanent structures to enhance the area (pergola, compost structure). We have also received grants from the community to plant many fruit trees along the perimeter of the garden. The fruit from these trees has been enjoyed by those who visit the park or walk along it's perimeter, not just the gardeners. Please don't destroy something that is so incredibly special to so many people.
Angie
As a nighbor and member of the Virginia avenue community garden, I do not support his option. The current space of the Virginia Avenue garden must be protected as its invauluabe green space for dozens of Captiol Hill families who garden here.
Many garden families have invested significant hard work and sweat into making this garden our brief respite from city living. Please don't destroy the only "outdoor" space that some of our childen and other families have.
Destroying the garden is not the action of a good neighbor and member of our community.
Christy Przystawik
Thank you for providing an easy outlet for community input. My husband was one of the founding members of the Virginia Avenue Community Garden and our family has been quite literally been living off of our garden plots for almost seven years now. The garden is not just our hobby, it is a way of life for our family (including four children) and for many others as well. Since it’s inception this garden has helped beautify Virginia Avenue, stimulate social interaction among generations and cultures in the community, reduce crime in the immediate area, preserve precious green space, reduce family food budgets, and feed many of the severely poor people around the garden. Needless to say I do not support this or any option that takes our garden away. In addition, a relocation of the garden would mean the loss of space and soil that has been tended for years, a necessity in the formation of a well-established, healthy, and productive garden. I also do not support the relocation of the garden.
Kim
My husband and I moved to the Capitol Hill East neighborhood a little over 2 years ago and were thrilled to get a plot in the Virginia Avenue Community Garden. Previous posters commented on how much sweat and community involvement have gone into the garden, and we can vouch for that. We worked 10-hour days for a month of weekends to build and plant our plots. Because we are by the fence and a picnic area, we are often asked questions by families, dog-walkers, tourists, and other passers-by. We not only explain what plants these folks are looking at, but we encourage them to apply for their own plot and make suggestions on what they could grow in containers while they are waiting. Most memorably, we helped a mother and her daughter to find a bunch of dandelions – in late August – for a school project. They thought dandelions were yellow and didn’t know that the puffballs we handed them were the same plant until we explained. At that moment, I realized just how much I’d taken for granted and how much I learned from growing up in the country. The community garden helps us demonstrate not only where food comes from and what it looks like while growing, it shows our urban neighbors that *anyone* can do it. I’m also extremely proud of our diverse garden membership and the many bees, birds, and insects that thrive in the park. I believe that a playground and dog park would be great additions to the spot and allow for more educational opportunities, and I hope the Marine Corps can find a different location for their needs. Given how close the park is to the interstates and major roadways, and given the security measures required, it doesn’t seem like a good choice for their building site.
Thomas
Why is there no option for the East Side of 11th and south of M Street. Currently there is a Huge flat parking lot east of the General Dynamics building that could be used for the BEQ. The parking could easily be replaced by a garage on the North Side of M Street or in the flat lot between the office buildings.
This will isolate the small amount of residential space between 10th and 7th flanking it on the east, west and south with gated military grounds.
Helen
I totally agree that there should be an option here.
Stephanie Schierholz
I live in an apartment, and Virginia Avenue Park is the closest green space I have, and I am very grateful for it. Moreover, my husband and I spent a year on the wait list to get a plot in the Virginia Avenue Garden. We were new to gardening, and we have discovered something great! The garden not only feeds us but also keeps us connected to the community and the neighborhood. We have put a lot of hard work into our plot and the community's garden, and I know that the committee and founders have poured far more effort into it. The garden has become one of my favorite things about living where we do. We may not be large in number, but the park has a large positive effect in the neighborhood. Please don't take it away from us. Won't you be a good neighbor?
Jane Malone + Dean Snyder
Land is scarce in Capitol Hill. Community gardening involves collective responsibility, opportunities to work the soil, healthy eating, locally grown food - commodities that are even more scarce in Capitpl Hill. This is a real city neighborhood: our homes don't have the eighth and quarter-acres of private space that suburbs provide. The Va. Ave. garden IS our back yard.
Please don't plan to "pave paradise." Repurposing the garden's land and/or moving the garden to a more environmentally hostile location are lose=lose propositions.
You have a lot of power. Please do not use it to undermine our community.
Joseph Konrad
I'm a member of the Virginia Avenue Community Garden. While I'm only a second year garden member, other garden members preceding me for years have worked hard to build a peaceful, beneficial neighborhood resource. I won't bore you with the green blah-blah about clean air and local food. It's simply plain to me that it's unequivocally a good thing and ought to be preserved long after I'm gone.
Unfortunately, it is now becoming clear that this space ("the Exxon and Virgina Ave. Park" as it is being called) is now a target for use for the needs of others, evening though it is my understanding plans were in the works to complement the garden with a renovated park that includes including a dog-park feature.
I am not against progress, and I have the greatest respect for the young men and women of the Corps; I find them always to be courteous and well-spoken members of the Hill neighborhood, and they deserve the best living quarters possible. However there are other parcels of land that could be used to achieve such an aim without bulldozing one of the remaining green patches on the Hill. I strongly urge the vacation lot called "Square 882" be used, which would bring the existing MBW Annex into contiguity with the Navy Yard.
Joseph Konrad
Cecelia Rogers
Our first lady, Michelle Obama, recently said "I'm a big believer in community gardens, both because of their beauty and for their access to providing fresh fruits and vegetables to so many communities across this nation and the world." That describes the role of the Virginia Avenue Community Garden perfectly. Please save the community garden.
Traci Hall
Given the area discussed, I am opposed to altering the green space that is left in this area south of the freeway. The park is used by members of the community as well as the garden. The community has come together and created an amazing and beneficial garden space that should remain unchanged. Please consider other options that do not alter existing recreational space that area is becoming very developed and needs some balance.
David Foster Hall
Give me your tomatoes, your squash, and your bedraggled end of the season kale, and I will be an eternal city dweller! These simple vegetables (and many others) planted in the warm spring soil by the hands of mothers and fathers and their children, coming together as neighbors to commune and laugh and serve the common good-- to reap, to learn of nature, and sustenance, and all that can grow and be good and bountiful amidst city streets and asphalt... these are pure things in our lives and the lives of our children that define our community. We are proud of our Marines who too serve the common good, but do not take away our community garden for housing. Our garden is our return to simplicity, to calm, to sell sufficiency and reverence for the earth we were given. We are it's stewards. Let us continue to till and teach our children what we can, as city dwellers, about our small green patch of land next to the busy freeway that too often reminds us of who we have become.
Kitty Barksdale
There is something inherently wonderful about working the earth, nurturing plants and the soil in which they are housed, and reaping the rewards of your labor. This is one of the myriad of benefits that our little garden in Virginia Avenue Park affords. It offers community, opportunities to learn, and a space for the all-too-overlooked chance to chill out and forget, if only for a short time, the inevitable work and life stresses that we all experience. This garden is far more than sixty or so small plots of land tended to by residents of the Hill. It is a refuge, an unspoiled simple pleasure, and for some, a sensory experience beyond compare. It gives me great pleasure to have this garden in which I can experiment, explore and understand the inherent connection between man and his/her environment. Should our military personnel be afforded quality, safe and excellent housing - absolutely. Should area residents be afforded one of the few green spaces left to them for gardening? Absolutely. There are other options on the table to consider, and removing an established garden - one that the gardeners in our community have earned and not been given (see www.marines.com) - is neither honorable nor proud.
Karin
Green space is crucial to the health of a city - there was a good reason this was made into a park, and that should not be dismissed. Also, this park is used greatly by area citizens! It's hard to imagine there isn't a better solution - like rehabbing a non-park building somewhere nearby. There are plenty of them, and they do not have to be directly next door to the existing Marine Barracks. Marines can do a tiny bit of commuting, just like most other people! It seems they want to turn this area into a Crystal City - instead of embracing the area for what it has to offer. I move to find another spot for the Marines and leave this and all of our parks in place! I placed this comment under every plan, because I think that it's really important that we are a "green" city who values our parks!
Meredith
Caveat: while not a gardener there, I appreciate the current green space on VA Ave, agree that a garden under an overpass isn't a practical idea(as proposed in the pdf), and encourage the incorporation of community green space/dog park/garden in this general area into the Marine plan. I'm sure that any incoming military families would also appreciate such a space and it would improve their quality of life as well.
However--
I'm actually a fan of this plan, overall. In the absence of other clearly articulated improvement plans for this area between 8th and 11th/M and VA Ave, putting Marine housing, parade grounds, etc. on this space seems like a decent use of an area that currently (excepting garden) is an eyesore. Especially that utterly depressing M St. frontage. Would be interested in more detail re: plans for Van Ness area green space. I don't know that we have grounds to believe the design would be a "concrete jungle" as some fear--certainly the Barracks are an attractive addition to the neighborhood, as is the annex, comparatively, and it's reasonable that the Marines will continue this pattern and build something both functional and attractive.
@Karin, as the longest-residing (we're talking centuries) and most committed residents of this community through good times and horrible times, I'm willing to let the Marines have priority and not relegate them to some distant commuter locale convenient for us residents and inconvenient for them. For security reasons, among others, it seems they should be close to the "8th & I" HQ, and I don't begrudge them that. (n.b. I am not connected to the Marines.)
Meredith
Noticed that the Washington Navy Yard Option 2 would improve at least part of the M St frontage (Exxon site) without interrupting green space and provides a secure location for military housing. Although the WNY Opt2 doesn't develop as much of the M St between 8th and 11th as the Exxon Option 1 plan, its features give it an edge on the Exxon Option 1 plan in my mind.
D. Cole
Not only does this option displace a burgeoning community garden and nascent dog park, it appears to place the barracks dangerously close to the highway and railroad tunnel -- isn't that why it's being moved in the first place?
I think lot 882 or the Naval Yard are far superior for those reasons. The Naval Yard location makes the most sense of all -- not only does the government already own the land, it's also within an established security perimeter.
Luke
Right now that end of M street looks TERRIBLE - if this option would bring development to that part of M I would be in favor of it (though block 882 and turning L street into an open green space is still my first option).
Return to Region
Post a comment
|